Skip to main content

Couples Academy

My Spouse Cheated. Should I Cheat Back?

Hasani Pettiford in the Couples Academy video on whether to cheat back after being betrayed

In short: No. The urge to get even is understandable, but a revenge affair rarely brings the relief people expect. It is done to hurt, so it lands differently, and it leaves a marriage with pain on both sides, each partner competing over who was hurt worse. If you are tempted, push pause, don’t act in pain, and get help.

Watch: Surviving infidelity: should I stay after my spouse cheated? The pull toward revenge (Hasani Pettiford, Couples Academy Show)

Key takeaways

  • After discovery, many betrayed partners swing between staying, straying and leaving. That ambivalence is normal.
  • Some feel tempted to do what their spouse did, to hurt them the way they were hurt.
  • Most affairs are selfish, not aimed at the spouse. A revenge affair is aimed at hurting, so the motive and the impact are different.
  • Revenge often leaves both partners competing over who is in more pain.
  • When both spouses have been unfaithful, recovery becomes far more complicated.
  • Even an agreed “hall pass” tends to deepen hurt rather than resolve it.

Why the urge is so strong

After an affair, it is common to feel pulled in opposite directions: stay, stray or go. Your mind, heart and emotions can all say different things, and that confusion can leave you stuck. In that hurt place, some betrayed partners feel tempted to do what their spouse did.

It usually isn’t about wanting someone new. It sounds more like this: I was faithful, I kept my vows, I honored you, and you didn’t. You hurt me, so I am going to hurt you. For some it is tit for tat; for others it is about doing something even bigger.

Why a revenge affair lands differently

Hasani isn’t comparing affairs to excuse either one. But he points out a difference in motive. Most people who have an affair are being selfish: they are trying to fulfill something in themselves, and the damage to their spouse is the consequence, not the goal. As one man in a Couples Academy group put it, he didn’t wake up one day deciding to destroy his family.

A revenge affair is different. It is done on purpose to hurt. Because the intent is different, it lands differently.

What it does to a marriage

  • Pain on both sides. Now each of you has been hurt, and couples often start competing over who is in more pain, or who hurt whom worse. It becomes a tug-of-war.
  • More conflict, not less. Couples get colder, shut down, and fight more. Hasani calls this the “sufferer” marital pattern.
  • Harder recovery. When both spouses have been unfaithful, each is dealing with a double pain. It easily becomes “I only did this because you did that,” and nobody takes ownership.
  • It rarely gives what you hoped. Many people find that what they were looking for, they already had at home, but the damage is done.

Revenge can also escalate in dangerous ways. If you or anyone in your home is at risk of harm, your safety comes first. See the important note at the bottom of this page.

What about a “hall pass”?

Some couples agree to let the hurt spouse have an outside encounter, to even the score. Even when both agree, Hasani has seen the pain, the memories and the dynamics prove too much to overcome. Inviting someone else into your marriage doesn’t resolve the hurt; it adds to it.

What to do with the urge instead

Push pause. Don’t make decisions in haste or in pain. The anger you feel is real, and it deserves a safe place to go: talking it through, with a guide, as part of a real recovery process, whether you ultimately stay or leave.

Go deeper

Hasani and Danielle Pettiford’s Trusting Again: How to Build New Trust When the Old Trust Is Gone is written for the partner who was betrayed. See it in our store →

Frequently asked questions

Is it normal to want to cheat back after being cheated on?

Yes, the urge is common. Many betrayed partners feel pulled between staying, straying and leaving. Feeling the urge is different from acting on it.

Will a revenge affair make me feel better?

Rarely for long. It is done to hurt, so it lands differently, and it usually leaves both partners in more pain.

Is a revenge affair worse than the original affair?

We don’t compare affairs. But the motive is different: most affairs are selfish, while a revenge affair is aimed at hurting the spouse, and that changes how it lands.

Can a marriage recover if both spouses cheated?

It is possible, but more complicated. Each partner carries both roles, and recovery has to take turns addressing each betrayal without “I only did it because you did.”

What about agreeing to a hall pass?

Even when both agree, it tends to add pain rather than resolve it.

Related questions

Get started

Book a free, confidential 30-minute discovery call with Hasani and Danielle. We’ll listen, and tell you honestly what we think the next step is.

Book a free discovery call   Call or WhatsApp +1 470-771-6254

Not ready to talk yet? Take the free Affair Recovery Assessment, or get our free guide, Your First 30 Days After Discovery.

Important note: Couples Academy provides relationship coaching, marriage support, and educational resources, not licensed therapy. If you are in immediate danger, experiencing abuse, domestic violence, or a mental health emergency, please contact emergency services or a qualified crisis resource in your area.

Talk with us about your situation

Book a free, confidential 30-minute call with our team. We'll listen, help you see where things stand, and talk through what to do next.

Book Your Free 30-Minute Call

Not ready to talk yet? Take the free Affair Recovery Assessment and get a personal report.

Important note: Couples Academy provides relationship coaching, marriage support, and educational resources, not licensed therapy. If you are in immediate danger, experiencing abuse, domestic violence, or a mental health emergency, please contact emergency services or a qualified crisis resource in your area.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *