Just found out about an affair? Start here: what to do first →
By Hasani Pettiford · Last updated November 4, 2026
In short: Usually, what your spouse felt was not love but an intense feeling Hasani calls “affair love”: the rush of newness and escape, with none of the bills, hurts or history a marriage carries. Authentic love is more than a feeling. It combines passion, caring love and the enduring love that holds a marriage through hard seasons, and what is missing in your marriage can be rebuilt.
Watch: Affair love vs. authentic love (Hasani Pettiford, Facebook Live)
Key takeaways
- “Did you love them?” is one of the first and most painful questions a betrayed partner asks.
- The pull of an affair partner is newness and escape: no shared bills, hurts, failures or responsibilities.
- Love is more than a feeling. A marriage needs passion (eros), caring love (phileo) and God’s enduring love (agape).
- In caring love, there is a “giver” and a “taker” in each of us. Healthy love keeps them in balance.
- Hasani and Danielle have had seasons when they fell out of love, and had to fall in love again on purpose.
- For the hurt partner: you can be free of constant comparison. What is missing can be rebuilt, with the right help.
Why this question hurts so much
When an affair comes out, one of the first questions is often, “Did you love them? Do you love them?” An affair is painful enough. The thought that your spouse gave someone else not just their body but their heart, mind and emotions can make it much harder to recover. That is why many people find the emotional side of an affair the hardest part.
What “affair love” really is
At the start of most relationships there is an “in love” feeling: you would do anything for each other. Over time that feeling gives way to a different kind of love, and many couples wonder where the passion went.
An affair brings that feeling back. It is new, fresh and different, and the unfaithful partner may feel things they haven’t felt in years. They may even think they have found their soulmate. That is the deception. What makes an affair partner so alluring is that the two of them share no hurts, no failures, no bills and no responsibilities. The affair is an escape from real life, and that feels like love. Hasani calls it affair love: it looks authentic, but it isn’t.
Most people in an affair never seriously think of making a life partner out of that person. Something about them doesn’t fit a real partnership. They represent what Hasani calls the “dangerous partner profile.”
Authentic love has three parts
- Eros: the passionate, romantic “in love” feeling. It is the feeling an affair imitates.
- Phileo: caring love. Drawing on Dr. Willard Harley’s book Fall in Love, Stay in Love, Hasani describes a “giver” and a “taker” in each of us. Early on, the giver comes out; over time, the taker rises. Healthy caring love keeps the two in balance.
- Agape: God’s love, described in the love chapter of 1 Corinthians: patient, kind, keeping no record of wrongs. It is what lets a marriage endure seasons when you feel like giving up.
A marriage needs all three. Caring love is sustainable, but the passionate, in-love feeling matters too, and it doesn’t come back by accident.
Falling in love again, on purpose
Hasani is open about this: there have been seasons in his marriage with Danielle when they fell out of love. What came naturally at the start, like gifts, quality time and meeting each other’s emotional needs, had to become intentional. After a storm, the house may still be standing, but it needs repair. That is where recovery begins.
Part of that work is learning how your spouse needs to be loved. Many of us love our partner the way we want to be loved, not the way they need to be loved. Rediscovering your partner’s emotional needs is part of bringing the in-love feeling back.
If you can’t stop comparing yourself
If you are the hurt partner, you may be tormented by the thought that your spouse fell out of love with you and in love with someone else: what does she have that I don’t, what does he do that I don’t? Hasani’s message is that what your spouse felt was not really love, and whatever is missing in your marriage can be regained if you are both willing to do the work. You may not have the knowledge or skills to do it alone, and that is what the right help is for.
Go deeper
Hasani and Danielle Pettiford’s The Audacity of Marriage: 10 Principles for Life-Long Partnership is a blueprint for building a marriage that lasts. See it in our store →
Frequently asked questions
Did my spouse really love the affair partner?
In most cases, what they felt was not authentic love but an intense feeling of newness and escape that Hasani calls “affair love.” It feels real, but it is built on fantasy and secrecy, not on a shared life.
Why is an affair partner so attractive?
Because there are no shared bills, hurts, failures or responsibilities. The affair is an escape from real life, and that freedom can feel like love.
What is the difference between affair love and authentic love?
Affair love is mostly a feeling. Authentic love includes passion, caring love and enduring love that holds a marriage together through hard seasons.
Can we fall back in love after an affair?
Many couples do, but it takes intention. What came naturally at the beginning, like quality time, affection and meeting each other’s emotional needs, has to be rebuilt on purpose.
How do I stop comparing myself to the affair partner?
It helps to understand that what your spouse felt was not really love. Comparison keeps you stuck. Focus on what can be rebuilt in your marriage, and get help if you are struggling with it.
Related questions
- Can cheating and love coexist?
- My spouse had an emotional affair. What now?
- My spouse is grieving the affair partner. Is that normal?
- Can a relationship that started as an affair last?
- Affair recovery: where to start
Get started
Book a free, confidential 30-minute discovery call with Hasani and Danielle. We’ll listen, and tell you honestly what we think the next step is.
Book a free discovery call Call or WhatsApp +1 470-771-6254
Not ready to talk yet? Take the free Affair Recovery Assessment, or get our free guide, Your First 30 Days After Discovery.
Important note: Couples Academy provides relationship coaching, marriage support, and educational resources, not licensed therapy. If you are in immediate danger, experiencing abuse, domestic violence, or a mental health emergency, please contact emergency services or a qualified crisis resource in your area.